Dr AL Sharada
Jan 14, 2022

Creative critique from a gender lens: 3-7 January

Dr AL Sharada, director, Population First, reviews a selection of ads from last week

Creative critique from a gender lens: 3-7 January
What worked
 
 
It is for the first time that I have seen an ad for adult diapers featuring an elderly woman. And, a woman who is so full of life and chutzpah, enjoying a cricket match wearing her team's T-shirt and the dry pants to not miss any part of the match. It is not very often that we find women, leave alone elderly women, enjoying sports. Women have more issues of incontinence as they age and we must speak about it without a sense of shame. 
 
Gender Sensitivity Score (GSS): 4.5/5
 
It is a very positive and empowering ad. It shows three young women meeting at a bar to have a good time, thus normalising women going to a bar, which is often looked down upon in some segments of our society. It makes the unsolicited intrusion of the man sending a drink to the young woman look so uncool. Finally, it shows the young woman dealing with this intrusion with dignity and poise putting the man in his place.
 
GSS: 4.5/5
 
What didn't work
 
The ad once again falls into the trap of showing mothers as having no other ambition than to get involved in their child's activities. How about a woman opting for Kellogg's for breakfast, so that she has some time for herself while the child is getting her nutrition. So empowering for both! Too radical a thought?
 
GSS: 2.5/5
 
 
The ad once again glorifies the whole practice of hordes of family members coming to 'see' the girl in an arranged marriage context, which should be avoided to stop the practice that could be very humiliating to many young women. The young woman is shown as not being her confident self but playing to the audience. Though humorous, the ad does not portray the woman in a positive light. 
 
GSS: 2.5/5
 
Other ads from last week:
 
Cred 
GSS: 3/5
 
GSS: 3/5
 
GSS: 3.5/5
 
GSS: 3/5
 
GSS: 3/5
 
 
GSS: 3/5
 
 
 
Source:
Campaign India

Related Articles

Just Published

47 minutes ago

M&A deals continued to decline in 2024: COMVergence

Even as overall dealmaking declines, certain sectors such as ecommerce continue to be a major draw.

2 hours ago

Interpublic reports $94 million loss for Q1 2025

The loss was fuelled by $203 million in costs for 'strategic restructuring actions'.

2 hours ago

Australia and India lead the Grand Prix tally at ...

Spikes Asia 2025 concluded tonight in Singapore with Ogilvy named Network of the Year, Colenso BBDO Auckland and EssenceMediacom taking home top honours, and Kazakhstan joining the winners’ circle for the first time.

23 hours ago

Havas invests in Ostro's AI platform

This investment in the AI-led platform will support Havas Health Network, boost Havas Creative and Media Networks, and refine the agency's media precision.